Mechanisms of Education Funding in the US are Racist

First, let me express my grief on behalf of people of color, and, at this moment, I mean African Americans in particular, who, even in 2020, even in the midst of a pandemic, must try to live meaningfully with the specter of racism threatening their lives. People who deny racism’s profound, continued negative impact on our culture are the same as people who deny the virility of Covid-19, people so simple in their thoughts (if not in words and actions) that they can’t engage with things they don’t experience firsthand.

I can only imagine how frustrating it must be for people of color to hear their reality debated in the media as some kind of hypothetical, over and over, even as videos of police and vigilante murders proliferate. The anger and destruction we see with the riots is the inevitable outcome of this frustration. Maybe we should have had an open and honest discussion about racism when football players were kneeling, which was a poetic and peaceful form of protest. If we had listened and worked toward meaningful change when we had the chance, perhaps there would be no riots. Perhaps George Floyd, Ahmaud Arbery, and others would still be alive. 

Please read and listen to people color right now. Listen and empathize. I can’t tell you anything they can’t share more effectively. 

As an educator, I feel it is necessary to point out ways in which my industry perpetuates racism and inequality. The structure of education funding and access in our country is extremely racist, classist, anti-worker, and anti-American. What do I mean? 

The cost of higher education and the ways those costs are structured deny access and mobility disproportionately to people of color, but negatively impact all working class people in the US, including white people. Because of automation and outsourcing, the investor class no longer needs nor cares about American workers and so we have seen the cost of college rise exponentially while wages have stagnated. Wages have stagnated, but investment income as grown.

Corporate tax break after corporate tax break pushes the cost of funding an educated populace away from the industries who rely on educated workers and onto the workers themselves. The investor class is divesting from their fellow citizens. Working class Americans are a bad investment compared to robots or people working for starvation wages in the developing world. Keep in mind that many of the people in the investor class benefited from cheap higher education access in the 1960s, 70s, and 80s, but deny others the same opportunities they themselves used to get ahead.

For white Americans, this divestment hits working-class Americans the hardest, yet, ideologically these people support the investor class and make the divestment in education possible. One of the main points of leverage the investor class uses to manipulate working-class white people into voting against their own self-interest is racism. Homophobia and religious fundamentalism are also exploited. If you’re not rich, but you are racist, you are a sucker falling for the oldest trick in the book – divide and conquer.

It’s a vicious cycle. Policies deny people education so they will be less informed and less intelligent, making them easier to manipulate and exploit. People are exploited into accepting less remuneration for our labor, less from our public institutions, and more inequality. We are exploited into accepting these ridiculous education funding models.

I have seen so many times when finances have prevented someone from continuing their education, even at the relatively inexpensive community college where I teach. Because I teach in Tucson, the majority of the students I’ve met who have had to abandon their education for financial reasons are LatinX. I also know many people struggling with massive college debt.

Denying access to education is intentionally racist policy aimed at perpetuating segregation. 

For example, Governor Doug Ducey completely de-funded community colleges in Arizona. This prevents working people and people of color from transcending their current economic statuses in our state. This is intentionally creating a barrier to accessing education and upward mobility. It is racist economic policy by racist legislators. Doug Ducey is a racist pandering to the investor class. In AZ, that means international mining corporations that care about our resources but don’t want to invest in the state’s residents, especially our Mexican and Mexican-American residents.

Research indicates that education affects people’s beliefs about race. Specifically, the more education you have, the more likely you are to believe in society-wide, structural barriers to upward mobility for people of color. Less educated people tend to believe there is something inherent in people or cultures that prevent them from being successful and see the playing field as more or less neutral. Research as to whether education changes people’s attitudes toward practical policy making is less clear-cut; there is some evidence that even though more educated people believe in structural causes for racism, they still don’t support targeted interventions aimed a promoting racial equality. I’ve linked a couple sources at the conclusion. Attitudes aside, we can discuss policies that affect access to education.

State colleges and universities must be free! All people deserve the chance to learn and improve their lives and communities,  not just those lucky enough to have parents who can afford it or those willing to take on massive debt. Many people work to fund their education, but, unlike previous generations, they cannot fully cover the cost. Often, working lower-wage jobs can’t even meaningful diminish the overall cost of a degree.

The way we fund public k-12 education is also racist. School districts are mostly funded by property taxes. Funding that relies on property taxes from neighborhoods surrounding the schools means that nice neighborhoods get great schools while struggling neighborhoods get struggling schools. Children face unequal opportunities based on the economics of their communities. What is a child’s liability in their own access to education?

Using local property taxes as the public school funding mechanism is racist. Because of historic segregation, people of color are much more likely to attend underfunded and struggling schools. Funding schools this way perpetuates segregation and racist law enforcement further denies opportunities. Drug laws provide the arbitrary infractions needed to keep up racist segregation through incarceration.  

Poorly funding predominantly low-income white school districts produce uneducated people who are more easily manipulated with media propaganda, which is what the investor class relies on to perpetuate the benefits they derive from systemic racism. For-profit prisons are a perfect example. You have to be pretty uneducated and/or lack basic critical thinking to believe that allowing investors to profit off prisons is a humane idea.

School funding must occur at the state level. Funds must be strategically distributed with a more holistic view of the statewide economy and benefiting all communities, not just those with already-high property values. Neighborhood-level school funding is antiquated, obsolete, and racist.

After 17 + years in education, I fully believe our funding mechanisms for k-12 and higher education in the United States have been developed to intentionally block pathways out of poverty. I believe that education funding is the new mechanism to maintain segregation. Poor people are prevented from accessing education on purpose to keep them uninformed, easy to control, and unable to compete economically. This primarily disenfranchises people of color. 

The best way to overcome racism is to improve access to education and improve the quality of education our institutions provide.

Free college? Some people object to the idea because they had to pay. To them I say, do not be so selfish! You are being exploited through your selfishness! If you had to struggle to get your education, if you went into debt or worked three jobs, you were intentionally disenfranchised. Do not demand that others, future generations, share your unfair suffering. If someone had fought for your education access, you would have avoided unnecessary suffering and sacrifice. Be someone who fights so that other have it better, not someone who vindictively perpetuates the inequality you suffered.

There are literally riots going on during a pandemic. We are waiting for a treatment for Covid-19.

We have the treatment to fight racism – equal access to high-quality education. We need everyone to take their anti-racism vaccine. We need equitable education access, including free state colleges and universities, now!

The Impact of Education on Inter-Group Attitudes: A Multiracial Analysis

The Effects of Education on Beliefs About Racial Inequality

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s